Soviet and post-soviet Islamic revivalin a Tatar village in Mordova

I.R. Minnullin

116-145 p.



The author of this article examines the contemporary Islamization of the Tatar village Belozer’e in Mordova in the context of the village’s particular socioeconomic development. While Mordova as a whole was characterized by a massive emigration from rural areas in the late Soviet period, the Tatar population of Belozer’e continued to grow. Although the kolkhoz declined, regional authorities displayed a surprising lack of concern for Belozer’e, which allowed the “shadow” economy to flourish. At the same time, Islam was developing locally without much attempt at institution building. Nonetheless, the case demonstrates that social differentiation in the wake of private entrepreneurship, and that continued ethnic and confessional isolation and of the non-interference of Soviet authorities left palpable imprints on the course of reIslamisation after the collapse of the Soviet regime. In the village there are several religious societies, each of which is tied to a muftiate. Also Belozer’e has introduced Islamic non-conformism, however, limited only at the end of the 1990s.


Keywords: Belozer’e, kolkhoz, Islam, Islamic revival, Mordova, private economy, re-Islamisation, Soviet period, post-Soviet period, Tatars


REFERENCES

1. Arkhiv Belozer’evskogo sel’skogo soveta [The Archive of Belozer’e’s Village Council]. Informatsiya po territorii Belozer’evskogo sel’skogo poseleniya (2009 g.) [Information on the Territory of Belozer’e Rural Settlement (2009)].

2. Asabin I.Yu. Obshchestvenno-politicheskoe, ekonomicheskoe i sotsiokul’turnoe razvitie Mordovii serediny 1960-kh – pervoy poloviny 1980-kh gg. [The Sociopolitical, Economic and Sociocultural Development of Mordova from the mid–1960s to the early 1980s]. Dissertatsiya na soiskanie uchenoy stepeni kandidata istoricheskikh nauk [Dissertation for Scientific Degree of Candidate of Historical Science]. Samara, 2009.

3. Bikkinin I. Vnezapnyy vizit [The Sudden Visit]. Tatarskaya gazeta – Tatar Gazette. 1998, June 28.

4. Bikkinin I. Islamskiy fundamentalizm v Mordovii? [Islamic Fundamentalism in Mordova?]. Tatarskaya gazeta – Tatar Gazette. 1998, May 27.

5. Braslavskiy L.Yu. Islam v Chuvashii [Islam in Chuvashia]. Cheboksary, Chuvashia Publ., 1997. 159 p.

6. Gosudarstvennyy arkhiv Rossiyskoy Federatsii (GARF) [State Archive of Russian Federation]. F. R–6991 (Sovet po delam religioznykh kul’tov pri Sovete Ministrov SSSR) [The Council for the Affairs of Religious Cults Under the Council of Ministers of the USSR]. Op. 3. D. 572 (Materialy o rabote Upolnomochennogo Soveta po delam religioznykh kul’tov pri Sovete Ministrov SSSR po Mordovskoy ASSR, 1946–1948 gg.) [Materials of the Commissioner of the Council for the Affairs of Religious Cults Under the Council of Ministers of the USSR for the Mordovan ASSR, 1946–1948].

7. GARF. F. R–6991. Op. 3. D. 575 (Materialy o rabote Upolnomochennogo Soveta po delam religioznykh kul’tov pri Sovete Ministrov SSSR po Mordovskoy ASSR, 1955 g.) [Materials of the Commissioner of the Council for the Affairs of Religious Cults Under the Council of Ministers of the USSR for the Mordovan ASSR, 1955].

8. GARF. F. R–6991. Op. 6. D. 2551 (Otchety, spravki, informatsii i perepiska s upolnomochennymi Soveta po voprosam deyatel’nosti religioznykh organizatsiy v Mordovskoy ASSR, 1983 g.) [Reports, Certificates, Information and Correspondence with Commissioners of the Council on the Activities of Religious Organizations in the Mordovan ASSR, 1983].

9. GARF. F. R–6991. Op. 6. D. 3455 (Otchety, spravki, informatsii i perepiska s upolnomochennymi Soveta po voprosam deyatel’nosti religioznykh organizatsiy v Mordovskoy i Severo-Osetinskoy ASSR, 1987 g.) [Reports, Certificates, Information and Correspondence with Commissioners of the Council on the Activities of Religious Organizations in the Mordovan and North Osetian ASSR, 1987].

10. GARF. F. R–6991. Op. 6. D. 3705 (Otchety, spravki, informatsii i perepiska s upolnomochennymi Soveta po voprosam deyatel’nosti religioznykh organizatsiy v Mariyskoy, Mordovskoy, Nakhichevanskoy ASSR, 1988 g.) [Reports, Certificates, Information and Correspondence with Commissioners of the Council on the Activities of Religious Organizations in the Mari, Mordovan and Nakhichevan ASSR, 1988].

11. Guseva Yu.N. Islam v Samarskoy oblasti [Islam in the Samara Oblast’]. Moscow, Logos Publ., 2007. 112 p.

12. Guseva Yu.N. Istoriya tatarskikh sel’skikh obshchin Nizhegorodskoy oblasti v XX veke (1901–1985 gg.) [History of Tatar Rural Communities in Nizhny Novgorod Oblast in the Twentieth Century (1901–1985)]. Nizhny Novgorod, NNGU Publ., 2003. 256 p.

13. Devyataev A.S. Islam v Respublike Mordoviya v 1990-e gg. – nachale 2000- kh gg. (sotsiokul’turnyy i etnopoliticheskiy aspekty razvitiya) [Islam in the Republic of Mordova from the 1990s to beginning 2000s (Sociocultural and Ethnopolitical Aspects of Development]. Avtoreferat dissertatsii na soiskanie uchenoy stepeni kandidata istoricheskikh nauk [Dissertation Abstract for the Degree of Candidate of Historical Science]. Saransk, 2010.

14. Zadkova T.Yu. Kolkhoznaya derevnya Mordovii v seredine 1950-kh – pervoy polovine 1960-kh gg. [The Kolkhoz Village of Mordova from the mid–1950s to the First Half of the 1960s]. Dissertatsiya na soiskanie uchenoy stepeni kandidata istoricheskikh nauk [Dissertation for Scientific Degree of Candidate of Historical Science]. Saransk, 2005.

15. Kil’dyushkina I.G. Sotsial’no-ekonomicheskoe razvitie Mordovii (vtoraya polovina 1980-kh – seredina 1990-kh gg.) [Socioeconomic Development of Mordova (Second Half of the 1980s to the mid–1990s)]. Dissertatsiya na soiskanie uchenoy stepeni kandidata istoricheskikh nauk [Dissertation for Scientific Degree of Candidate of Historical Science]. Saransk, 2004.

16. Koroleva L.A., Korolev A.A. Musul’manskie obshchiny Penzenskoy oblasti vo vtoroy polovine 1940–1980-e gg. [Muslim Communities of Penza Oblast from the Second Half of the 1940s – 1980s]. Obshchestvo i lichnost’: istoriko-pravovye aspekty vzaimodeystviya [Society and Personality: Historical and Legal Aspects of Interaction]. Penza, PF MOSU Publ., 2004, pp. 69–74.

17. Kosach G.G. Orenburgskaya oblast’: regional’nyy aspekt postsovetskogo razvitiya rossiyskogo musul’manskogo soobshchestva [Orenburg Oblast: The Regional Aspect of the Development of Russian Muslim Society], Pax Islamica, 2009, № 1, pp. 162–198.

18. Lukin V. Est’ li uprava na spekulyanta? [Is There Justice for the Speculator?]. Sovetskaya Mordoviya [Sovet Mordova]. 1987, September 1.

19. Mamedova M. Belozerskie plennitsy [Belozer’e Prisoners]. Available at: www.trud.ru/article/14-06–2002/41853_belozerskie_plennitsy.html (accessed: 4.03.2012).

20. Martynenko A.V. Selo Belozer’e kak sotsiokul’turnyy fenomen Belozer’e Village as a Sociocultural Phenomenon]. Vlast’ i krest’yanskiy sotsium Srednego Povolzh’ya v istoricheskoy retrospektive: mezhvuzovskiy sbornik nauchnykh statey. Pod. red. Nad’kina T.D. [Power and Peasant Society in the Middle Volga Region in Historical Perspective: Inter-University Collection of Scientific Articles. Ed. by T.D. Nad’kin]. Saransk, 2009, pp. 179–184.

21. Mukhamed’yarova L. Deti podsolnukha [Sunflower Children]. Available at: www.novayagazeta.ru/society/15879.html (accessed: 4.03.2012).

22. Mukhametshin R.M. Tatary i islam v XX veke (Islam v obshchestvennoy i politicheskoy zhizni tatar i Tatarstana) [Tatars and Islam in the Twentieth Century (Islam in the Social and Political Life of Tatars and Tatarstan)]. Kazan, Fen Publ., 2003.

23. Nad’kin T.D. Stalinskaya agrarnaya revolyutsiya i krest’yanstvo (na materialakh Mordovii) [Stalin’s Agrarian Revolution and the Peasantry (in Mordovan Materials)]. Saransk, Kur’er-S Publ., 2006. 303 p.

24. Nad’kin T.D., Yusupov R.R. Kollektivizatsiya tatar-misharey Mordovii v nachale 1930-kh gg. [Collectivization of the Mishar Tatars of Mordova in the Beginning of the 1930s]. Vlast’ i krest’yanskiy sotsium Srednego Povolzh’ya v istoricheskoy retrospektive: mezhvuzovskiy sbornik nauchnykh statey. Pod. red. Nad’kina T.D. [Power and Peasant Society in the Middle Volga Region in Historical Perspective: InterUniversity Collection of Scientific Articles. Ed. by T.D. Nad’kin]. Saransk, 2009, pp. 108–112.

25. Sagitova L.V. Regional’nye i lokal’nye aspekty islama v Povolzh’e: sotsial’nye osnovaniya razlichiya [Regional and Local Aspects of Islam in the Volga Region: Social Bases for Difference]. Konfessional’nyy faktor v razvitii tatar [The Confessional Factor in the Development of Tatars]. Kazan, 2009, pp. 125–162.

26. Salimov M.Sh. Protsess formirovaniya tsentralizovannykh musul’manskikh organizatsiy v Respublike Mordoviya [The Process of Formation of Centralized Muslim Organizations in the Republic of Mordova]. Sotsial’no-demograficheskie problemy Povolzh’ya v etnicheskom izmerenii [Sociodemographic Problems of the Volga Region in the Ethnic dimension]. Saransk, 2007, pp. 293–301.

27. Salimov M.Sh., Makarov D. Altary [Altary Village]. Islam v Tsentral’noEvropeyskoy chasti Rossii: Entsiklopedicheskiy slovar’ [Islam in the Central European Part of Russia: Encyclopedic Dictionary]. Moscow, Medina Publ., 2009, p. 18.

28. Salimov M.Sh., Makarov D. Belozer’e [Belozer’e Village]. Islam v Tsentral’no-Evropeyskoy chasti Rossii: Entsiklopedicheskiy slovar’ [Islam in the Central European part of Russia: Encyclopedic Dictionary]. Moscow, Medina Publ., 2009, p. 44.

29. Salimov M.Sh., Makarov D. Musul’manskaya obshchina Mordovii v XX v. [The Muslim Community in Mordova in the Twentieth Century]. Islam v Tsentral’noEvropeyskoy chasti Rossii: Entsiklopedicheskiy slovar’ [Islam in the Central European Part of Russia: Encyclopedic Dictionary]. Moscow, Medina Publ., 2009, pp. 198–200.

30. Semenov V.V. Islam v Saratovskoy oblasti [Islam in the Saratov Oblast’]. Moscow, Logos Publ., 2007. 113 p.

31. Silant’ev R. Noveyshaya istoriya islama v Rossii [The Latest History of Islam in Russia]. Moscow, Algoritm Publ., 2007. 576 p.

32. Stolitsa S. 2007, December 18.

33. Stolitsa S. 2008, May 22.

34. Stolitsa S. 2008, July 7. 35. Stolitsa S. 2008, October 27. 36. Stolitsa S. 2011, August 11. 37. Telin I. V Mordovii est’ svoi vakhkhabity [Mordova has its Wahhabis]. Available at: www.pravda.ru/news/world/03-07–2000/908626-0/ (accessed: 4.03.2012). 38. Khalikov R. Belozer’e – primer dlya podrazhaniya [Belozer’e – an Example to Follow]. Islam v Mordovii – Islam in Mordova. 2010, December 3.

39. Tsentral’nyy gosudarstvennyy arkhiv Respubliki Mordoviya (TsGARM) [Central State Archive of the Republic of Mordova]. F. 76-P (Romodanovskiy raykom partii) [[Romodanovo District Party Committee]. Op. 1. D. 11 (Protokoly i vypiski iz protokolov byuro RK VKP (b), dokladnye zapiski o sostoyanii partiynoy raboty, o khode kollektivizatsii v rayone, 1929–1933 gg.) [Protocols and Extracts from the Protocols of the District Committee Bureau of the CPSU (b), Reports on the State of Party Work, the Progress of Collectivization in the District].

40. TsGARM. F. R–234 (Prezidium Verkhovnogo Soveta Mordovskoy ASSR) [Presidium of the Supreme Council of the Mordovan ASSR]. Op. 4. D. 216 (Proekt Ukaza Prezidiuma Verkhovnogo Soveta Mordovskoy ASSR o zakrytii mecheti v sele Belozer’e Lyambirskogo rayona, 14–19 dekabrya 1940 g.) [[Draft Decree of the Presidium of the Supreme Council of the Mordovan ASSR to Close the mosque in Belozer’e in the Lyambir’ District, December 14–19, 1940].

41. TsGARM. F. R–662 (Mordovskoe respublikanskoe upravlenie statistiki) [Mordova Republican Statistical Office]. Op. 27. D. 2804 (Godovye otchety kolkhozov, 1965 g.) [Annual Reports of the Kolkhozes, 1965].

42. TsGARM. F. R–662. Op. 37. D. 2439 (Godovye otchety kolkhozov, 1980 g.) [Annual Reports of the Kolkhozes, 1980].

43. TsGARM. F. R–662. Op. 37. D. 2821 (Spiski naselennykh punktov MASSR na 1 yanvarya 1980 g.) [Lists of Settlements in the Mordovan ASSR January 1, 1980].

44. TsGARM. F. R–662. Op. 38. D. 49 (Godovye otchety kolkhozov, 1985 g.) [Annual Reports of the Kolkhozes, 1985].

45. TsGARM. F. R–662. Op. 38. D. 968 (Spiski naselennykh punktov MASSR na 1 yanvarya 1985 g.) [Lists of settlements of the Mordovan ASSR January 1, 1985].

46. TsGARM. F. R–662. Op. 40. D. 2373 (Edinovremennyy otchet o polovom i vozrastnom sostave sel’skogo naseleniya, 1990 g.) [One-Time Report on the Sex and Age Composition of the Rural Population, 1990].

47. TsGARM. F. R–1055 (Romodanovskiy Sovet deputatov i ispolkom) [Romodanovo Council of Deputies and Executive Committee]. Op. 1. D. 416 (Materialy po voprosam religioznykh kul’tov, 1964–1971 gg.) [Materials on the Question of Religious Cults, 1964–1971].

48. TsGARM. F. R–1233 (Inspektura gosudarstvennoy statistiki Romodanovskogo rayona) [Inspection of the State Statistics of Romodanovo district]. Op. 1. D. 152 (Godovye otchety o polovom i vozrastnom sostave sel’skogo naseleniya, 1964 g.) [Annual Reports on the Sex and Age Composition of the Rural Population, 1964].

49. TsGARM. F. R–1233. Op. 1. D. 267 (Godovye otchety o polovom i vozrastnom sostave sel’skogo naseleniya, 1973 g.) [Annual Reports on the Sex and Age Composition of the Rural Population, 1973].

50. TsGARM. F. R–1594 (Lyambirskiy rayonnyy Sovet deputatov) [Lyambir’ District Council of Deputies]. Op. 1. D. 18 (Dokumenty o khode kollektivizatsii i raskulachivanii krest’yanskikh khozyaystv v rayone, 1935 g.) [Documents on the Progress of Collectivization and the Dispossession of Farms in the District, 1935].

51. TsGARM. F. R–1594. Op. 1. D. 36 (Dokumenty po voprosam religioznykh kul’tov, 1936 g.) [Documents on the Question of Religious Cults, 1936].

52. TsGARM. F. R–1594. Op. 1. D. 56 (Spiski naselennykh punktov rayona s ukazaniem chislennosti naseleniya i khozyaystv (materialy predvaritel’nogo ucheta naseleniya, podgotovlennye ko Vsesoyuznoy perepisi naseleniya 1939 g.), 1938 g.) [Lists of Settlements in the District Indicating Population and Households (Materials of Preliminary Population Count in Preparation for the All-Union Census in 1939), 1938].

53. TsGARM. F. R–1594. Op. 1. D. 81 (Dokumenty o zakrytii mecheti v s. Belozer’e i Cheremishevo, 1940 g.) [Documents about Closing the Mosques in Belozer’e and Cheremishevo, 1940].

54. TsGARM. F. R–1597 (Lyambirskaya rayonnaya inspektura narodnokhozyaystvennogo ucheta pri Lyambirskom ispolkome) [Lyambir’ District Inspection of the National Economic Accounts Under the Lambir Executive Committee]. Op. 1. D. 11 (Edinovremennyy otchet o vozrastnom i polovom sostave sel’skogo naseleniya, 1947 g.) [One-Time Report on the Sex and Age Composition of the Rural Population, 1947].

55. TsGARM. F. R–1597. Op. 1. D. 39 (Edinovremennye otchety sel’sovetov o vozrastnom i polovom sostave sel’skogo naseleniya Lyambirskogo rayona, 1954 g.) [One-Time Reports of the Village Soviet on the Sex and Age Composition of Lambir District, 1954].

56. TsGARM. F. R–2488 (Kolkhoz «Yanga Turmysh») [New Life Kolkhoz]. Op. 1. D. 8 (Godovoy otchet kolkhoza, 1950 g.) [Annual Report of the Kolkhoz, 1950].

57. Shilov N. Selo Belozer’e kak etnokonfessional’nyy fenomen [Belozer’e Village as an Ethno-Confessional Phenomenon]. Byulleten’ Seti etnologicheskogo monitoringa i rannego preduprezhdeniya konfliktov [Bulletin of the Network for Ethnic Monitoring and Early Warning]. 2001, May 16–31, pp. 10–12.

58. Yakupov V. Islam v Tatarstane v 1990-e gody [Islam in Tatarstan in the 1990s]. Kazan, Iman Publ., 2005. 144 p.

59. Yumaeva G. Izge kөshelər [Holy People]. Tatarskaya gazeta – Tatar Gazette. 1999, August 4.

60. Minnullin I. Sun Flower and Moon Crescent: Soviet and Post-Soviet Islamic Revival in a Tatar Village of Mordova. Allah’s Kolkhozes. Migration, De-Stalinisation, Privatisation and the New Muslim Congregations in the Soviet Realm (1950s–2000s) / Stephane A. Dudoignon, Christian Noack (eds). ISLAMKUNDLICHE UNTERSUCHUNGEN BAND 314. Berlin: Klaus Schwarz, 2014, pp. 421–453.

61. Sagitova L. Traditionalism, Modernism and Globalization Among the Volga Muslims: The Case of Sredniaia Eliuzan. Allah’s Kolkhozes. Migration, DeStalinization, Privatization and the New Muslim Congregations in the Soviet Realm (1950s–2000s) / Stephane A. Dudoignon, Christian Noack (eds). ISLAMKUNDLICHE UNTERSUCHUNGEN BAND 314. Berlin: Klaus Schwarz, 2014, pp. 454–493.

About the author: Ilnur R. Minnullin – Candidate of Science (History), Deputy Director, Sh.Marjani Institute of History of the Tatarstan Academy of Sciences (Entrance 5, Kremlin, Kazan 420014, Russian Federation); i.minnullin@gmail.com


Received 16.05.2016   Accepted for publication 04.10.2016

Published Online 17.11.2017